Home
Blog Car Care Advice 7 Bad O2 Sensor Symptoms (Is It Safe to Keep Driving?)
Car Care Advice

7 Bad O2 Sensor Symptoms (Is It Safe to Keep Driving?)

Looking for a mechanic near you for maintenance or repair? AutoNation Mobile Service brings the shop to you. Get a free instant quote today.
Get a Quote

Bad O2 sensor symptoms, when left unchecked, can result in poor engine performance and harmful emissions.

But how long do oxygen sensors typically last?
And can you prevent these issues before they start? 

Explore signs of a malfunctioning O2 sensor, uncover the root causes, and learn why you should get a failed O2 sensor fixed ASAP.

This Article Contains

7 Bad O2 Sensor Symptoms You Shouldn’t Ignore

Your car uses many unique sensors, but the oxygen sensor is one of the most important. It measures exhaust oxygen levels and sends that data to the powertrain control module (PCM), which is your car’s computer. The PCM uses the data to adjust your engine’s air-fuel mixture to improve fuel mileage and reduce emissions, helping your vehicle run smoother.

Clearly, a failed oxygen sensor can cause huge issues. Here are signs you might have a bad oxygen sensor:

1. Blinking or Illuminated Check Engine Light

A continuously lit or flashing check engine light (CEL) is usually the first sign of a failed oxygen sensor. However, the check engine light can signal many other problems. You’ll need an OBD II scanner to read the engine light codes and pinpoint the exact issue.

2. Reduced Fuel Economy

A faulty oxygen sensor can result in poor gas mileage. It provides incorrect readings to the PCM, leading to an imbalanced air-fuel mixture. This imbalance then causes the engine to run either too rich (excess fuel) or too lean (insufficient fuel), reducing fuel efficiency and increasing fuel consumption.

An increased RPM (revolutions per minute) is an early sign of this issue. If your RPM is high when idle, the engine is working harder than usual, even when not under load.

3. Engine Misfiring, Rough Idling, or Stalling

Oxygen sensor issues can disrupt the air-fuel mixture and engine timing, causing incomplete or irregular combustion. This can lead to engine misfires or rough idling. In extreme cases, a persistent problem with the fuel and O2 levels can result in abrupt engine stalling.

4. Engine Knocking or Pinging Sounds

A bad O2 sensor can cause excessive carbon deposits (a black soot-like substance) in the combustion chambers, which may disrupt the air-fuel ratio. This build-up often leads to a lean mixture, resulting in poor engine performance, pre-ignition, and loud noises such as engine knocking or pinging.

5. Engine Overheating

When sensor failures result in a lean air-fuel mixture, the engine works harder to produce power. The extra workload generates more heat, which can cause your engine to overheat if left unchecked. So, if you observe your car running hotter than usual, it could be the result of a bad O2 sensor.

6. Black Smoke or Bad Smells From the Exhaust Pipe

The rich air-fuel mixture from a bad oxygen sensor can lead to incomplete combustion within the engine. In such cases, your vehicle may release black smoke and a foul sulfur smell through exhaust fumes.

7. Malfunctioning Catalytic Converter

The catalytic converter’s role is to reduce harmful exhaust gas emissions. However, when a faulty O2 sensor disrupts the air-fuel ratio, excess fuel can escape the combustion chamber and enter the catalytic converter. These conditions can cause the catalytic converter to overheat or clog.

A bad catalytic converter can increase exhaust gasses beyond acceptable pollutant limits, and your vehicle will likely fail an emissions test.

Note: None of these symptoms alone are conclusive evidence of a broken oxygen sensor. You should consider them alongside other indicators.

Next, let’s dive into what a failing oxygen sensor means for your safety on the road.

Is It Safe to Drive with a Bad O2 Sensor?

No, driving with a faulty oxygen sensor isn’t safe. 

While you can technically drive with a broken oxygen sensor, that doesn’t mean you should.

Because vehicles produce significant exhaust gasses, oxygen sensors are critical for efficient combustion. These unique sensors measure O2 levels so the PCM can keep the engine’s air-fuel mixture just right and ensure it burns at an optimal ratio.

If the ratio is off, the engine may run too rich or too lean, leading to improper fuel combustion. This affects engine performance, increases emissions, and can strain the catalytic converter, which can get costly.

Since it contains rare and valuable metals, a new catalytic converter could raise your repair bill from a few hundred dollars to between $500-$2,000.

If the check engine light stays on or flashes, promptly pull over and tow your vehicle to an auto repair shop for inspection.

So, how long do you have before issues start popping up?
We’ll reveal the average lifespan you can expect from oxygen sensors.

How Long Does an O2 Sensor Last?

O2 sensors on older cars typically perform effectively for around 30,000 to 50,000 miles. In contrast, new vehicles have improved sensors with a heating element, helping them last up to 100,000 miles.

Always follow your vehicle manufacturer’s recommendations for exact replacement intervals.

Modern vehicles usually have at least four oxygen sensors positioned at key points in the exhaust system. Two upstream sensors, situated before the catalytic converter, regulate the engine’s air-fuel mixture, while two downstream sensors evaluate the converter’s effectiveness by analyzing exhaust gas emissions.

Replacing only the faulty sensor is often sufficient. However, getting new O2 sensors in pairs can be more convenient since they have similar lifespans and may fail around the same time.

Next, let’s see what you can do to prevent these issues.

How to Make O2 Sensors Last Longer

A functioning O2 sensor is vital for optimal engine performance, emission control, and the durability of your exhaust pipe and exhaust manifold.

Here are some expert tips for the proper upkeep of your oxygen sensor:

That said, you’ll still need to get new O2 sensors over time because they wear out naturally.

Got more questions on your mind? 
We’re here to help!

3 FAQs About O2 Sensors

Here are answers to some common queries about oxygen sensors:

1. What Are the Main Causes of a Malfunctioning O2 Sensor?

You may experience symptoms of a bad oxygen sensor due to various factors. 
Here are the primary culprits:

2. How Do You Diagnose a Bad Oxygen Sensor?

You can try to diagnose a faulty O2 sensor yourself to confirm potential problems. However, if you’re not confident with car parts or reading trouble codes, it’s best to consult a professional mechanic when you suspect trouble.

But if there’s a real problem, they’ll check for several OBD II codes that report O2-specific issues (such as P0130 or P0136).

3. How Much Does it Cost to Replace a Bad O2 Sensor?

The cost of replacing a bad oxygen sensor can vary depending on your vehicle and the type of oxygen sensor. Another factor is whether you opt for an OEM O2 sensor replacement or an aftermarket sensor. However, the part and labor costs for a new oxygen sensor typically range from $100 to $300.

Fix a Bad O2 Sensor Fast with AutoNation Mobile Service

Recognizing a failed O2 sensor is vital for preventing severe issues and reducing future repair costs.

But what if you need a new oxygen sensor?
That’s where AutoNation Mobile Service steps in. 

Our auto repair experts can diagnose symptoms of a bad oxygen sensor and conveniently fix them right from your driveway. Plus, you’ll enjoy peace of mind with a 12-month, 12,000-mile warranty on all repairs.

Get a quote today for an oxygen sensor replacement, oil change, or any other vehicle service!